top of page

Commentary: Zach Bryan’s Young Manhood and Other Donatable Organs EP

Nicholas Cakes
Nov 9
3 min read
Zach Bryan performs during the Quittin Time tour at Nissan Stadium on June 29, 2024 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo credit: Keith Griner/Getty Images)
Zach Bryan performs during the Quittin Time tour at Nissan Stadium on June 29, 2024 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo credit: Keith Griner/Getty Images)

Zach Bryan, known for his folky, country and raw music challenges his very image he has built: being inspired by one's saddened struggles.


From “DeAnn”, recorded in an Airbnb with his Navy buddies, harnessing the pain of a young man who lost their favourite person too soon, to With Heaven On Top, a folk-infused album at his wit's end of his own struggles and tales of burning the candle at both ends through his own self-destructive male tendencies in between, this record shows a new message from Zach. 


Maybe we are capable of being better?


His style of songwriting is bare, raw, unapologetic, but after 2024, some fans felt it was falling off. 


This eight-track EP shows a return to the emotional powerhouse songwriting he achieved at his height and there are two keys that he himself accredits to the shaping of this record: marriage and sobriety. 


In a two-hour long interview he uploaded on his YouTube channel, he details meeting his wife, her effect on him as a man and the process of finally quitting alcohol as he transitioned into his 30s and how combined, he found that spark again.


Anyone who follows him on TikTok definitely recognize “Lodi When”, singing it acapella with his backup singers before a show, but this record starts with something no country purist will expect: synth and electric keys. 


They set the atmospheric tone from note one and the inclusion of the catchy hook and the acoustic guitar, it takes a more typical Zach Bryan vibe, but offers more compositionally than previously. 


This song offers this question: if you looked back on your life and wrote a book about it, what would be important to feature? What was truly important? The parties? The drinking? Or the people you love? 


Is this a groundbreaking track? No, but the familiarity with and demand from the fans to feature it on the album, it is a very smart idea to make “Lodi When” the track to open the record. 8.3/10


“Robot Killed The Working Man” opens with an excerpt from a world-famous professional wrestling promo from The American Dream Dusty Rhodes, chronicling the “hard times” of workers who after 30 years get laid off so “a computer will take your job.”


This song is Bryan’s message against AI, big businesses using it and other forms of tech putting hard-working people into very hard circumstances and this recording gives a Noah Kahan quality to the mix and composition. 


He talks about how his grandmother’s hometown has changed so much after big business came in, replacing literature with phones and just how tragic life becomes when we lose the means of providing for ourselves and keeping in touch with our humanity, simply for the sake of “innovation.” 9.1/10


The standout song of the entire EP would be “Lies” featuring Lana Del Rey. This song is just a piano, a violin and two performers who wield emotion like a fencing sabre, trading verses back and forth like a couple who can only afford one drink but can’t bear not to share it. 


Usually songs that are bare in the composition and mix like this are hard to pull off, but with the simplicity of the song structure and the emotion of the lyrics, they pull it off. 


Most of all, Del Rey is in her element and this song and its lyrics fit her like a glove, she does not miss. If the last 20 seconds featured an increase in the keys and strings instead of incorporating an acoustic, this song would be perfect. 9.7/10.


In “Dog Days” Bryan takes his love of Bruce Springsteen and combines it with an optimism that before this record wasn’t very prevalent in his songwriting. 

He romanticizes the “dog days”, singing to his wife that this healing journey he is on is going to be a wild ride, one not to miss. 


It is the most fast-paced and energized song of the record, but with how short the song is, it makes the song feel like it is missing a verse, instrumental, or a bridge, which is a common criticism and inside joke with his discography. 7.8/10



Comments


bottom of page