top of page

Moot court gives STU undergrads a taste of the courtroom at first Tommies Cup

Writer: Polina Kozlova
Polina Kozlova
Nov 9
2 min read
Jordyn Grant and Brayden Bruce, who placed second, during the final round. (Photo credit: Jordyn Grant)
Jordyn Grant and Brayden Bruce, who placed second, during the final round. (Photo credit: Jordyn Grant)

St. Thomas University (STU) students argued the constitutionality of a mandatory minimum sentence at the university’s first Moot Court Tommies Cup, a competition that gave undergraduates a taste of what law school will demand.


Harshene Kaur and Liam MacDougall placed first. Brayden Bruce and Jordyn Grant finished second.


About a dozen teams took part, most of them from STU. The case centered on child exploitation and the mandatory minimum sentence attached to it.


Competitors did not know which side they would argue until they walked in. They could be the Crown, defending the sentence, or challenging it.


“You kind of go in blank,” Grant said. “You have to make arguments for both sides.”


The first day was point-based and every team advanced to the second day. After that, the competition became a knockout. Teams that won their round moved on until two were left.


Grant and Bruce argued for the Crown in the final against Kaur and MacDougall, who took the defence. Grant said eight or nine judges watched and the other competitors stayed to see the round. The judges deliberated for 45 minutes before naming the winners.


Grant called it an competitive last round. 


“They did absolutely amazing,” she said of the winning team.


The tournament was organized by Amanda DiPaolo, STU’s head moot court professor and the university will host it again in coming years.


STU offers the only for-credit undergraduate moot court program in Canada, according to the university. 


Grant said its students often compete against law schools and that while preparing for another case, some law students at UNB did not recognize the issues STU students were already working through.


“It’s really cool just to have an undergrad school learn so much about what other people are learning way later on,” she said.


Grant is in her fourth year, majoring in criminology with a minor in psychology. She plans to start applying to law schools in January.


She said moot court has given her skills she expects to use there. Competitors have to read cases, find the relevant law, build an argument and present it to judges who may not agree.


“They may not like your arguments, but you just kind of have to go with it and prove what you know,” she said.


It also taught her parts of the Criminal Code and Charter rights in a way studying from a textbook does not.


“It’s a very hands-on way of learning things instead of studying from a book, which I quite enjoy,” Grant said.


She valued the collaboration too. Competitors argued against friends and classmates and picked up ideas from one another.


“It’s all just a big collaborative space to make your arguments even better,” she said.


For Grant, the result mattered less than how far the students had come. She said she recently reread some of her early arguments and found them far weaker than what she delivered in the final.


“It was just night and day,” she said. “You can truly tell that the hard work has definitely paid off.”


Comments


bottom of page